Skip to main content.
Menu

Mystery Disease: Tests for Whooping Cough Are Expensive and Slow

Mystery Disease: Tests for Whooping Cough Are Expensive and Slow

Picture of William Heisel

Certainty: That I am being . That the drugs I’m taking aren’t going to be worse for me than the disease. That the horrible cough I had – so violent it – is something I can avoid in the future.

It's not always possible as Deborah Kotz described in a :

Doctors are stumped by symptoms all the time, and by prescribing the wrong medication, they often worsen the problem or even create a new one. Worse, misdiagnoses lead to an astounding 40,000 to 80,000 hospital deaths every year, according to a March paper published in the Journal of the American Medical Association— an uncounted number due to mistakes in the doctor's office. In fact, some 5 percent of autopsies find a condition missed by doctors that, if treated, might have saved the patient's life.

I wanted certainty, and I thought that getting tested for whooping cough would have provided me some.

But first I had to wait. My doctor told me the test results would take a week. That should have given me some certainty by July 19. I called the clinic, but the results weren’t in yet.

“It can take 10 working days after we send in the cultures, and we didn’t send them in until July 15. That should mean July 30.”

I called on the 30th. This time I was told there is typically a 12-day turnaround.

But I also was told something even more interesting:

“Pertussis is a fairly expensive test to run, so they hold the cultures until they have a batch of them and only run them once a week. They have to justify running the machine. The lab doesn’t even do them itself. They ship them to an outside source. The equipment is very expensive to buy and maintain.”

This seemed troubling. We are in the middle of a whooping cough resurgence. The first vaccination efforts drove the number of whooping cough cases down from a high of more than 250,000 nationwide in the 1930s to . New vaccination formulations in the mid-1990s and then the mid-2000s followed. But so did a rise in cases. In 2012, the number was climbing past 40,000 for the first time in more than 50 years. A commentary in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2012 called the .

The rise in cases is so alarming that state and federal public health agencies are constantly on the look out for new cases and deaths. The CDC reports the latest numbers weekly. As of the most recent report, there had been .

But state and federal agencies rely on doctors offices and laboratories to report positive test results and deaths from the disease. How can new cases be accurately captured if labs delay running the tests for weeks because they are too expensive to run?

I also wondered about whether the tests would be less effective the longer the specimen sat around. “They keep the sample refrigerated,” I was told. “When you’re talking about a virus, it’s all dependent on what the specimen is, and some have shelf lives for quite a period of time. The lab wouldn’t have a 12-day turnaround time if the specimen was not viable.”

Pertussis is caused by bacteria, not a virus. But I didn’t want to quibble. I just wanted my test results.

So I called again on what would have been the 12thday. When the test results were still not in. I asked if I could call the lab directly. Here’s what the lab at Northwest Hospital, where my specimen was sent, told me:

“The tests can take up to 15 days.”

So I asked whether this would put young children jeopardy. The disease is particularly fatal in kids, and it would seem that not knowing for 15 days whether there was a pertussis outbreak in, let’s say, a kindergarten class would be a huge problem.

“Oh no,” the woman in the lab told me. “If you were a child, they would have run your test already. They run the tests for children always before adults, and so you’re probably getting bumped back by tests for children.”

I decided to just stop calling and to stop worrying. I felt better. Either the drugs worked, or my health improved on its own.  

On Aug. 3, I received a letter in the mail from my doctor’s office. A full 22 days after I went in for an evaluation, the results on my test for whooping cough were in. And they were negative.

So what did I have? I probably will never know. But it is worth noting that the tests for pertussis have their own problems. As :

Culture is best done from nasopharyngeal (NP) specimens collected during the first 2 weeks of cough when viable bacteria are still present in the nasopharynx.  After the first 2 weeks, sensitivity is decreased and the risk of false-negatives increases rapidly.

By the time I saw a doctor, I had been coughing for more than two weeks, so I was in the decreased sensitivity window when she took my sample. The upshot? My negative test could be false. There’s no way to go back in time and get a better, earlier sample.

It’s been a lesson for me that often certainty is unattainable in medical care. It’s something my friends who are physicians and scientists live and breathe every day, but patients expect certainty from science.

With improvements in testing protocols; with better physician education about signs and symptoms; with more rapid and widespread reporting of the disease, we may get closer to certainty with whooping cough.

For now, I’m going to have to take it on faith that I had something nasty and – perhaps with the help of medicine – beat it. That’s a small victory. And I’m grateful for it.

Image by Amy Loves Yah via

Comments

Picture of

My two year old granddaughter tested negative yet has all of the symptoms. How do we get someone to run the other lab test that tests the blood?

Picture of

Excellent excellent article. I'm delighted to know I'm not alone in this.
We are kindred spirits in a sense, not wanting to just take drugs if we don't know what we have. Your story is very similar to mine.
My cough was so violent that I couldn't work, and I was also convinced I was dying of something serious. My test result for whooping cough is also negative, my doctor who is amazing, did the nose swab thing but it had been at least 3 weeks since my cough started, and I did learn from researching prior to taking the test, that longer length of time of having the cough could result in a false negative. Not sure what I had either but I'm very curious. What did you take to help your cough go away?
Strong ginger tea made my cough disappear initially, but it came back 2 weeks later more violent, I think I should have drank the ginger tea for two weeks like an anti-biotic, not stop drinking at as soon as the symptoms went away, I think that's where I went wrong. The persistence and ferocity of the cough made me go to the doctor, after seeing the doctor and refusing anti-biotics until I knew what I had for sure, and I got X-rays, even a tuberculosis test.
My lungs looked fine, tb test was negative.
I took germ warfare from Erewhon market, 1 bottle in 3 doses spread 3x's a day, up until about 5 days ago. It helped but
I Still had symptoms,
less violent but I was able
To Work if I drank raw cacao powder
And ginger tea together but wasn't raw anymore after I boiled it into a tea, right? I functioned with light coughing here and there. One day out
Of the blue the cough turned into
Sneezing
And flu like symptoms, runny nose, tired, that day I took a strong dose of raw cacao powder
And raw honey not in a tea, just mixed it with a spoon and ate it, just one dose and my flu-like symptoms went away the next
Day. I cough now maybe once a day lightly not sure if it's just reflexes now.
I
Will be back to the
Doctor for allergy tests and such. I would like to know what worked on your cough. Are you completely symptom free and did you take any antibiotics or
Antivirals or
Any
Other natural or
Otherwise therapies? Thank you for
an article pertinent to my issue.
I'm
Sharing
This on the web because I
Want anyone who
Is dealing with this to have as much information as possible and be well equipped.
Thank you!

Picture of

Wow. I have had Pertussis for a month now. I just got my (negative) swab results back. Here, in BC, Canada, it took only a week. I spent nearly two weeks "dry drowning" every night with laryngospasm. How many times a night can one feel close to death without some impact on the brain? NOBODY believes that a senior citizen can get pertussis (except for my random clinic doctor) I have lost 15 lb. YAY! I look like death-warmed-over. Boo! When I read your post about the flu-like symptoms (the runny nose has arrived) I was cheered. I'm not the only one!!. I am now the internet research Pertussis queen. It wasn't how I planned to spend the last month of summer. When did you finally feel human again? Please tell me you are still alive? :)

Picture of

I have all of the symptoms right now and my tests came back negative. I can't get a doctor's appointment until the first of June. Really? So here I sit, coughing and coughing, choking, coughing, choking, then I'm fine until the next episode. At least I know I'm not going to die from it since it has happened so many times, but I don't even know if I can leave the house.

Leave A Comment

Announcements

If you're a journalist with big ideas who wants your work to matter, the Center for Health Journalism invites you to apply for the all-expenses-paid-- five days of stimulating discussions in Los Angeles about social and health safety net issues, reporting and engagement grants of $2,000-$12,000 and six months of expert mentoring.

CONNECT WITH THE COMMUNITY

https://medicaments-24.com

steroids pills for sale

adulttorrent.org/details/makai_kishi_ingrid_ep_iii