Skip to main content.

Issue Worth Exploring: Raising the Medicare Eligibility Age May Harm Minorities

Issue Worth Exploring: Raising the Medicare Eligibility Age May Harm Minorities

Picture of Kimber Solana

Since GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney named Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) as his running mate, Medicare and plans to reform the program has dominated headlines.

Most of the media coverage has focused on Ryan’s proposal for a “premium support” option where seniors receive a fixed amount of money, a voucher, which they’d use to purchase insurance in a newly created Medicare marketplace.

However, the congressman’s plan to overhaul Medicare includes more than that.

J. Duncan Moore Jr., a contributor for and co-founder of the , looked into Ryan’s proposal to lift the age at which people become eligible for Medicare benefits from 65 to 67. Ryan’s plan, originally issued in March 2011, would increase the eligibility age for Medicare by two months a year starting in 2022, until it reached age 67 in 2033.

How would such a move impact seniors of color?

Moore wrote:

“The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that pushing eligibility to age 67 would reduce federal spending on Medicare by 5 percent. The CBO says most people would find substitute insurance through employers, spouses, and Medicaid or other government programs. Nevertheless, raising the age ‘amounts to a benefit reduction,’ the CBO says, and ‘a small share of those people would end up without health insurance.’”

However, opponents say the plan would be a raw deal for minorities.

“Raising the eligibility age ‘would negatively impact seniors of color because they tend to be in poorer health at earlier ages,’ said Maya Rockeymoore, chair of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, a Washington advocacy group. ‘Pushing back the age of eligibility decreases their ability to access the care they need.’”

Moore wrote that the issue cuts minorities two ways. First, minority groups tend to have lower salaries and lifetime incomes, making them more vulnerable to the financial pressures of purchasing private insurance. Second, Native Americans and African Americans have shorter life expectancies, meaning they would be paying into the program and less likely to reap the benefits, effectively subsidizing healthier, wealthier individuals.

Journalists should explore how raising the eligibility age impact residents and seniors in their local communities. There are so many questions to ask. Among them:

  • How many additional would-be beneficiaries will now become Medicaid-eligible? 
  • How will an increase in eligibility age impact the private market and state exchanges, which will absorb most of those waiting longer for Medicare? 
  • Would the government end up spending those savings from raising the eligibility age on other federal aid programs for those having difficulty obtaining insurance? 
  • Will seniors have to remain in the workforce longer just to maintain access to affordable insurance?

With the 2012 presidential race heating up, specific issues involving Medicare reform are worth exploring.

Read Moore’s piece:





Picture of

Great insight & questions Kimber... Most definitely worth exploring.

Picture of Tena Rubio

Thanks for taking a closer look at Rep. Paul Ryan's Medicare reform plan and sharing it here. You bring up good and important questions to look into. t.

Picture of

The fact is that Romney?Ryan plans for the destruction of medicare as we know it for younger citizens is in place. Obamacare
if overturned will place hardships on the elderly and on poor wage earners. Giving people vouchers to fill the coffers of private insurers is a remedy for disaster. Stay the course with Obama and his affordable healthcare act when tweaked will make this society kinder and gentler.

Leave A Comment


Join us on April 23 for insights and suggestions from physician and author Dr. Sunita Puri that will deepen your understanding and coverage of palliative care and end-of-life issues. Sign-up here!